
Indie auteur Kim Ki-duk has never been shy about embedding a message within his films. That's no exception with One on One, his didactic movie about the inherent evil of obedient capitalism. That's not the only message, comrade. For Kim's also critiquing inherited violence as a viable tool for effecting change. It's simply what we have that's readily available. We never really learn why the daughter of Ma Dong-seok's unnamed character has been murdered or exactly how this vigilante boss-man has managed to put together a camouflaged crew of six to exact revenge on those responsible for his child's death. I'm not even sure why one of the establishment's underlings gets gassed while another gets electrocuted while another gets his hand smashed by a hammer. There might be a logic that's evading me. The main message I'm receiving is this: Everyone is complicit; a few feel guilt.
Despite Kim's atypical casting of a bona fide action star (Ma Dong-seok) in the lead role, Kim's agitprop pic mostly adheres to an underground esthetic and a renegade style. The settings feel makeshift; the script was supoosedly written on site over a period of ten days; the violence looks fake; the dialogue is stilted. Don't get me wrong. I'm not dissuading you from watching this flick. Because One one One possesses a sense of purpose that makes it impossible to dismiss outright. The unpolished aspect of this film is the point, right? And if it isn't, it certainly could be.